Head-to-Head · 2026
MyFishingBuds vs Fishbrain
Fishbrain is one of the most popular fishing apps in the world. MyFishingBuds does something Fishbrain cannot — it helps you find someone to fish with. Here is how they compare.
Updated June 2026 · Pricing and features verified
Why we wrote this comparison
We built MyFishingBuds after a year of Fishbrain
MyFishingBuds did not start as a comparison page exercise — it started because the founder spent a full season logging catches in Fishbrain and realized the actual bottleneck was never spot data. It was finding somebody to fish with. Fishbrain is excellent at what it does: 14M catch markers, community forecasts, an enormous user base. None of that helps when you have a free Saturday and nobody on your contacts list is free, or when you are new to a town and do not know a single angler at the local ramp.
We tested both apps side-by-side for three weeks in June 2026 — same waters (south Florida inshore + offshore), same target species (snook, redfish, sailfish), and the same simple question: from cold start, which app gets me on the water with another angler fastest? The honest answer is that Fishbrain does not solve that problem at all — it is not built to. MyFishingBuds is. So this comparison is not "MyFishingBuds is better." It is "they answer different questions, and most anglers actually want answers to both."
Translation: use both. Use Fishbrain for the catch data and Fishidy-style spot research. Use MyFishingBuds to find the person and to keep your float plan filed. The rest of this page is a feature-by-feature breakdown of where each one shines, so you can decide which Pro subscription (if any) earns its keep.
MyFishingBuds
Best for: Finding a fishing partner
The only fishing app built for finding a compatible fishing buddy. AI trip planning, float plan safety, and fish ID.
Free forever · Pro $12.99/mo · 14-day Pro trial included
🐟 Fishbrain
Best for: Finding fishing spots
14 million catch locations, AI fish ID, fishing forecasts, and a community of 20 million anglers.
Free tier available · $9.99/mo Pro · $74.99/yr
Feature-by-Feature Comparison
| Feature | MFB | Fishbrain |
|---|---|---|
| Find a fishing partner | ✓ | — |
| AI Trip Planner (NOAA + USGS) | ✓ | — |
| Fish ID from photo | ✓ | ✓ |
| Float plans + GPS safety | ✓ | — |
| Emergency contact auto-alerts | ✓ | — |
| Trip creation with crew | ✓ | — |
| Fishing regulations by state | ✓ | — |
| Tackle logbook (AI photo ID) | ✓ | — |
| Catch log | ✓ | ✓ |
| Share catch, protect your spot | ✓ | — |
| Private waypoints + bud sharing | ✓ | — |
| Private catch journal (AI auto-fill) | ✓ | — |
| Catch heatmap | ✓ | ✓ |
| Large community (20M users) | — | ✓ |
| Fishing forecast / Bite Score | ✓ | ✓ |
Who Wins Each Scenario?
You want to find someone to fish with
Only app with buddy matching. Fishbrain has no partner-finding features.
You want the largest catch location database
14M logged catches — unmatched for spot discovery. MFB has a growing heatmap but smaller dataset.
You want a heatmap that protects your fishing spots
MFB only shows catches where the user explicitly shared publicly. Fishbrain requires location sharing to contribute at all.
Safety is a priority (offshore, solo boating)
GPS float plans and auto emergency alerts. Fishbrain has no safety tools.
You want AI-powered trip planning
Live NOAA, USGS, barometric, and solunar data in one plan.
You want to share catches without giving away your spot
Built-in spot privacy. Fishbrain's model requires location sharing to contribute.
You want private waypoints you can selectively share
Drop a spot only you can see. Send to a specific bud or open to trip crew — never forced public.
You want a private fishing journal
AI auto-fills species, GPS, and gear from a single photo. Completely private — separate from the feed.
You want a big fishing community
20M users, millions of shared catches, active forums.
You want a real free tier (forever)
Free forever (3 trip joins/mo, full safety). Pro is $12.99/mo vs Fishbrain Pro $9.99/mo but MFB Free goes deeper than Fishbrain Free.
You want fish ID from a photo
Both have AI fish ID. MFB also shows regulations for that species.
You are new to fishing
Learn-to-fish library, and finding a compatible bud beats solo spot-finding.
You want to teach others and grow the sport
Mentor Mode (Pro) puts you first in beginner Discover results — Fishbrain has no equivalent.
Where Fishbrain is Better
- 📍
Catch location data
14 million catches logged — Fishbrain has a much larger dataset for spot discovery. Both apps now have catch heatmaps, but Fishbrain's is denser (though it requires revealing your location to contribute).
- 👥
Community size
20 million users means more local reports, more species data, and more tips for every body of water.
- 📊
Community-based forecasts
Predicts activity based on where fish have been caught historically — useful for spot selection.
Where MyFishingBuds is Better
- 👥
Finding a fishing partner
The only app that matches you with compatible anglers. Fishbrain has no equivalent.
- 🛟
On-the-water safety
GPS float plans, automatic emergency alerts, and SOS — free on every plan.
- 🤖
Real-time Bite Score + AI trip planning
Live NOAA tides, USGS water conditions, barometric pressure, and solunar tables — current conditions right now, not historical averages.
- 📌
Private waypoints with selective sharing
Drop a spot — only you see it. Share with a specific bud via DM or open to your trip crew. Fishbrain forces location sharing to contribute to the community.
- 📓
Private catch journal
Separate from the public feed. AI auto-fills species, GPS location, and tackle from a single photo. Your personal fishing diary stays yours.
- 💰
Price
Free forever with real features (3 trips/mo + safety). Pro $12.99/mo vs Fishbrain Pro $9.99/mo. 14-day Pro trial included on signup.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is MyFishingBuds a good Fishbrain alternative?
It depends on what you need. Fishbrain excels at spot discovery and community catch data. MyFishingBuds is the better choice if you want to find a fishing partner, plan group trips, or need safety tools like float plans and GPS alerts.
Does Fishbrain have a buddy matching feature?
No. Fishbrain is a solo fishing app. There is no way to match with a compatible fishing partner. MyFishingBuds is the only app built specifically for finding a fishing buddy.
Which app has better AI — Fishbrain or MyFishingBuds?
Fishbrain: fish ID and spot prediction from community data. MyFishingBuds: AI Trip Planner (live NOAA, USGS, solunar), AI Fish ID with regulations, and an AI Fishing Buddy chatbot.
Does Fishbrain have safety features?
No. Fishbrain has no float plans, GPS tracking, or emergency alerts. MyFishingBuds includes GPS float plans, auto emergency contact alerts, SOS, and weather alerts — all free on every plan.
Can I log catches without sharing my fishing spot?
Yes — MyFishingBuds has a built-in spot privacy mode. When you log a catch, you can choose to share the catch (photo, species, weight, measurements) while hiding the exact GPS location. Your secret spots stay secret. Fishbrain is built around location sharing — contributing to the community requires revealing where you caught the fish.
Which is cheaper — Fishbrain or MyFishingBuds?
MyFishingBuds is free forever with a real feature set — profile, browse, 3 trip joins a month, and the full safety stack. Pro is $12.99/mo for unlimited trips and the AI toolkit; Fishbrain Pro is $9.99/mo. New MyFishingBuds accounts also get 14 days of Pro included automatically, with no credit card required.
Can I save fishing spots privately without sharing them publicly?
Yes — MyFishingBuds has private waypoints. Drop a spot on any trip or float plan and it is visible only to you. You can share it with a specific bud via direct message or open it to your trip crew when ready. Nothing is ever forced public. Fishbrain is built around community location sharing — to contribute to the heatmap you must reveal where you caught the fish.
Does MyFishingBuds have a private fishing journal?
Yes. The Catch Journal is completely separate from the public feed. When you add a photo, AI automatically fills in the species, date, GPS location, and any visible tackle. Your entries are private by default — you choose whether to share anything to the feed, and you control which details (weight, length, location) get included if you do.
The Bottom Line
Use Fishbrain if your primary goal is finding fishing spots and tapping into a large community. Its catch database is unmatched.
Use MyFishingBuds if you want to find a fishing partner, plan group trips, or need safety tools on the water — free forever, with Pro at $12.99/mo vs Fishbrain's $9.99/mo.
Get 14 days of Pro free
Free forever. Every new account also gets 14 days of full Pro included — no credit card. Safety always free.
Get Started Free →